Eduard´s
FW 190 A-8 , a verdict
Impressed
by the sheer mass of parts , the superb surface details , the colored
instructions, photo etch parts, masks and first comments from fellow modelers
the decision was taken, DO IT. During the dry fit of parts which is an
essential MUST with this kit (please, take your time) I recognized the amount of
time taken by the Eduard team to design and to construct this kit. Be
ensured , everything goes together rather well , only an absolute minimum of
putty was needed. The approach that was taken on this kit somewhat reminded me
to the early phase of Accurate Miniatures.
A
complete kit was to be produced avoiding the need of (expensive)
aftermarket stuff. But – this compromised in a tendency of over
engineering, as with early AccMin kits. If you belong to that kind
of modelers who prefer to present their models in clean condition with all
or most hatches, doors and other devices closed you will have to some
superfluous work like doing the complete not uncomplicated engine
construction. A more simple solution like on the DML/Dragon kit
would have done because engine details are virtually not visible behind
the cooling fan. And there are other features where a simplified
design and parts break down would have been satisfying (Main gear well,
inner canon bays). Eduard should have put all these parts for
“extra” detailing on a separate sprue and then offer an “super
detail kit”. Nearly reaching Hasemiya standards I found that the
fit of core (inside moulds) and cavity (outside moulds) where not 100% and
some cleaning up was needed. This problem found its peak with the
propeller which does not have the correct profile but with the help of
sandpaper an acceptable result can be reached. Others might use the
Dragon/DML blades.
Click on
images below to see larger images
I
personally hate gluing photo etch on outer panels , here the piano hinges
of the canon covers attached to the upper edge of the wing filets.
Why aren´t they moulded on ( in the result one of the weak points of the
model) ?
Priming
and finish with paint was done in two steps , so , please Wladimir, next
time two sets of masks in your kits (even if it is 50 Cents more).
The
decals work on very well , the carrier film is of first class quality and
in my example nearly perfect in register which necessitated some minimal
trimming with the national markings. What I didn´t like were the
colors used, they are simply too strong, the blue for the JG 5 machine has
by far too much red.
I
just wanted to represent a typical 190 and this was accomplished .
The paint job in brief words : automotive primer micromeshed , airbrushing with
Schmincke (artist) colors , Future/Klear , again micromesh , decaling and a
final coat with a water based flat varnish.
“External”
parts : canon barrels with 1.00mm brass , position lights from stretched clear
sprue (which works wonderful with styrene used by Ed) and the
pitot tube from an injection needle and a synthetic hair from a tooth brush.
A
kit , worth every Cent , Penny , Kopeck or other.
My
personal wish , might Eduard maintain the heritage of the real , the good , the
old Accurate Miniatures and those people who gave this brand a soul.
Andreas
|